I had a great conversation last night on Twitter about “silent reading” time. Some teachers feel it is a waste of time… that kids are more likely to become discipline problems during this time… that they’re not really reading… or that they’re not comprehending what they’re reading.
I disagreed. And now, as I think about it, I can disagree because our school values and intentionally cultivates a culture of reading. This culture provides time, choice, modeling, reading aloud (for all our classes, not only our “littles”), discussion with peers, options in how/what/why they read, but most importantly that reading books is something we ENJOY. Books are gifts. Books are treasures.
Some of the things we don’t do: reading logs, forced leveled readers, reading tracking programs, prescriptive reading lists, required reports/discussion/book conferences for every book a child reads, etc.. (Basically anything that takes away choice from kids.)
In my opinion – and 20+ years of teaching experience – those things kill the joy of reading. Those things tell kids, “Hey. I don’t trust that you’ll actually read this book unless I force you to complete something that proves you read it.” Those things don’t honor a student’s choice in what she wants to read. Those things tell kids that their reading is only valuable if they can talk to a teacher about what they just read.
THOSE THINGS ARE ABOUT THE ADULTS IN THE CLASSROOM… NOT THE KIDS. If we control their reading, they are not going to want to read.
In my classroom… Do we sometimes read a book together as a class and then discuss? Of course. Do we sometimes read books and then talk with a partner or small group about what we just read? Yes! Do we have book conferences? “Speed booking?” (like speed dating, but with books!) Do we discuss reading strategies, elements of a story, reading for entertainment, reading for information… YES. ALL THE READING THINGS!
But to me, it is vital that kids ALSO have time provided for them to simply read freely – with no expectations of the how/what/why.
One of my favorite days of our school year is called StoryLine. All the students share the work they’ve created throughout the school year and show their learning progress. Most of the kids like to include books they’ve read in this “display,” and when I visit other classrooms, I love to ask them why they selected the particular books in their display. I don’t hear, “Mrs. X said I had to include this book” or “Well, we had to read this as a class” or “I talked about this book in a book conference with my teacher.”
These kids say, “These are my three favorite books I read this year!” and “I read this book, and I really identified with what was happening with the characters in this book!” and “I had a really hard time picking favorites, because there were so many great books I read this year!”
As I was thinking about how to write this post, I found another post by my friend Pernille Ripp – and you should definitely read it. https://pernillesripp.com/2017/06/09/does-reading-for-pleasure-in-schools-really-make-a-difference/
Pernille is an extremely valuable resource for any educator, but she is also on of my list of “go to” teachers for anything having to do with reading and books.
So I wrote THIS post, because the “waste of time” comments regarding silent reading really struck a nerve within me. And I think the biggest takeaway for me after doing some processing and reflecting upon my own practice and reading habits is this:
If silent reading is a waste of time in your school, maybe it’s a CULTURE problem, not a KID or READING problem. And I would offer the following questions as thinking points – just something to consider:
- Do your students have choice in the types of books they read?
- Do students in your school have access to multiple genres? e-Books? Graphic novels? Comic books? Poetry? Picture books?
- If a student starts a book and doesn’t like it, does he have the option to try something else?
- How do the adults in your building model their own reading? Do the students SEE you reading?
- Most importantly… have you asked the KIDS how they could make silent reading a more enjoyable time?
When you see statistics like these gathered from Pew in 2015, as educators, we should be doing everything we can to help foster a love for reading. I’ve been a lover of books from a very early age, but I was happiest when I had choice, options, and access to what *I* wanted to read. When teachers gave our classes silent reading time with choice, I was a happy camper… AND that freedom made me much more likely to want to read the books they wanted me to read, too.
Books are gifts. Books are treasures. If your students don’t feel this way, this says more about the culture of reading in their environment than it says about them.
Thanks for taking the time to read this post.
A million times YES! I’ve had this same conversation so many times. In my classroom we start out our day reading or writing- anything you want. You can read alone or with a partner and the same thing occurs if the kid chooses writing. I don’t tell them which type of book to put in their book box but I do encourage them to choose different types of books. Some do, some don’t. 🙂 I do have conferences but it’s just set up so the student can tell me about their book and they decide questions before they read for it.
I don’t use reading logs or responses because to me that is the waste of time, not the silent reading. We have a book share day on Fridays. They kids share their favorite book from the week- any time of book from in class or from home. They do a quick book talk with a partner & then they do a quick share with the class.
I’ve had teachers tell me that they wonder how I know they are reading. I know they are reading because I hear them giggle or I see them take the book halfway across the room to share something they learned with a friend that shares that interest. They come up to me and say, “Hey, Miss Mac, guess what I just learned,” or they share a funny line or they ask me if we can get more of a certain series or by a certain author.
Isn’t this how we read? We share books titles with each other. I’ve yet to complete a reading response or reading log as an adult and I don’t think my students should either.
Reading is fun when teachers don’t kill it. 🙂
As a college educator and a parent, I could not agree more. My 8 yr old doesn’t love reading nearly as much as they did before school, and those reading logs are the WORST. I mean, honestly, *I* hate them.